🏫 The “Force It to Argue” Trick

Unlock deeper insights from AI by prompting it to debate both sides before giving a balanced conclusion.

đź“Ś Quick Context:

One of the best ways to extract deeper, more balanced insights from an AI is to push it into argument mode. By asking it to argue both sides of a topic before summarizing, you’re simulating critical thinking—and getting more nuanced, useful answers.

How to Do It in 3 Steps:

Step 1: Set up the prompt to argue for an idea

Start by asking the AI to make the strongest case in favor of an idea.

Example: “Argue in favor of using AI to replace human customer support.”

This primes the model to bring out the benefits, such as scalability, 24/7 availability, and cost savings.

Step 2: Flip it—ask it to argue against the idea

Now challenge the AI to take the opposing stance.

Example: “Now argue against using AI to replace human customer support.”

Expect insights like loss of empathy, customer frustration, and brand trust issues.

Step 3: Ask for a balanced summary or recommendation

Once both sides are laid out, ask the AI to synthesize the arguments into a nuanced conclusion.

Example: “Summarize the trade-offs and give a balanced recommendation.”

This encourages the model to weigh context—like when AI is appropriate and when human input is essential.

Try this technique on a current debate in your field—AI regulation, remote work, open-source models, etc. Use the resulting arguments in team discussions, strategy sessions, or content creation.

đź’ˇ Pro Tip:

You can push even further by adding constraints:

  1. “Now argue for it from a small startup’s perspective.”

  2. “Now argue against it considering long-term ethical risks.”

By making the AI your sparring partner, you unlock more thoughtful, informed answers—not just surface-level summaries.


Nick Wentz

I've spent the last decade+ building and scaling technology companies—sometimes as a founder, other times leading marketing. These days, I advise early-stage startups and mentor aspiring founders. But my main focus is Forward Future, where we’re on a mission to make AI work for every human.

👉️ Connect with me on LinkedIn

Reply

or to participate.